Renewable Energy Legal Defense Initiative

• Opposition to Renewable Energy Facilities in the United States: June 2025 Edition, in Columbia Law School's Scholarship Archive and engage with the data on the Sabin Center's interactive website, Opposition Report.
• Rebutting 33 False Claims About Solar, Wind, and Electric Vehicles, at Columbia Law School's Scholarship Archive. Read an adaptation of this report by Skeptical Science here. **DISCLAIMER: Given the enactment of H.R. 1 (Public Law No. 119-21) on July 4, 2025, the Sabin Center for Climate Change Law is working on updating the sections of this report that rely on provisions under the 2021 Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act (IIJA) and the 2022 Inflation Reduction Act (IRA) that were repealed and/or amended and no longer applicable.** 

Crossroads Solar I, LLC (Ohio)

• Reply Brief in Support of the Crossroads Solar Project, by Trent Dougherty (February 2026)

• Initial Post-Hearing Brief in Support of the Crossroads Solar Project, by Trent Dougherty (February 2026) 

• Motion to Intervene in the Matter of Crossroads Solar I, LLC, by Trent Dougherty (October 2025)

Eastern Cottontail Solar, LLC (Ohio)

• Brief of Allen Turnbull and Betsy Alt Contra Rehearing in the Matter of Eastern Cottontail Solar, LLC, by Trent Dougherty (September 2025) 

• Reply Brief of Allen Turnbull and Betsy Alt in Further Support of the Eastern Cottontail Solar Project, by Trent Dougherty and Matthew Eisenson (April 2025)

• Initial Post-Hearing Brief of Allen Turnbull and Betsy Alt in Support of the Eastern Cottontail Solar Project, by Trent Dougherty and Matthew Eisenson (April 2025)

• Motion to Intervene in the Matter of Eastern Cottontail Solar, LLC, by Matthew Eisenson and Trent Dougherty (November 2024)

Frasier Solar, LLC (Ohio)

• Brief of Ethan Robertson Contra Rehearing in the Matter of Frasier Solar, LLC, by Matthew Eisenson and Trent Dougherty (August 2025)

• Reply Brief of Ethan Robertson in the Matter of the Application of Frasier Solar, LLC by Matthew Eisenson, Jacob Elkin, and Trent Dougherty (October 2024)

• Initial Post-Hearing Brief of Ethan Robertson in the Matter of the Application of Frasier Solar, LLC by Matthew Eisenson, Jacob Elkin, and Trent Dougherty (September 2024)

• Motion to Intervene in the Matter of Frasier Solar, LLC, by Jacob Elkin and Trent Dougherty (February 2024)

Carnation Solar, LLC (Ohio)

• Motion to Intervene in the Matter of Carnation Solar, LLC, by Matthew Eisenson and Trent Dougherty (July 2025)

Oak Run Solar, LLC (Ohio)

• Amicus Brief of Dr. John Boeckl in Support of the Oak Run Solar Project, by Trent Dougherty and Matthew Eisenson (March 2025)

• Brief of Dr. John Boeckl Contra Rehearing in the Matter of the Application of Oak Run Solar Project, LLC, by Matthew Eisenson, Michael Gerrard, and Trent Dougherty (April 2024)

• Reply Brief of Dr. John Boeckl in the Matter of the Application of Oak Run Solar Project, LLC by Matthew Eisenson, Michael Gerrard, and local counsel Trent Dougherty (July 2023)

• Initial Post-Hearing Brief of Dr. John Boeckl in the Matter of the Application of Oak Run Solar Project, LLC by Matthew Eisenson, Michael Gerrard, and local counsel Trent Dougherty (July 2023)

• Motion to Intervene in the Matter of the Application of Oak Run Solar Project, LLC by Matthew Eisenson, Michael Gerrard, and local counsel Trent Dougherty (March 2023)

Almer Charter Township (Michigan) 

• Amicus Brief of Clara and Leonard Ostrander, Teresa Himes, and Kevin Heath in Support of Michigan Public Service Commission in Almer Charter Township v. Michigan Public Service Commission, by Mark Brewer, Rowan Coneybeare, and Matthew Eisenson (February 2025)

• Answer of Clara and Leonard Ostrander, Teresa Himes, and Kevin Heath in Almer Charter Township v. Michigan Public Service Commission, by Mark Brewer, Rowan Coneybeare, and Matthew Eisenson (December 2024) 

• Amicus Brief of Clara and Leonard Ostrander, Teresa Himes, and Kevin Heath in Almer Charter Township v. Michigan Public Service Commission, by Mark Brewer, Rowan Coneybeare, and Matthew Eisenson (December 2024)

Richwood Solar, LLC

• Reply Brief of Bruce Beery and Ashley Beery in the Matter of the Application of Richwood Solar, LLC by Jacob Elkin and Trent Dougherty (October 2024)

• Initial Post-Hearing Brief of Bruce Beery and Ashley Beery in the Matter of the Application of Richwood Solar, LLC by Jacob Elkin and Trent Dougherty (September 2024)

• Motion to Intervene in the Matter of Richwood Solar, LLC, by Jacob Elkin and Trent Dougherty (May 2024)

Clear Mountain Energy Center, LLC (Ohio)

• Motion to Intervene in the Matter of Clear Mountain Energy Center, LLC, by Matthew Eisenson and Trent Dougherty (June 2024)

Revolution Wind (Rhode Island and Connecticut) 

• (Second) Amicus Brief of Climate Action Rhode Island in Green Oceans v. U.S. Dep't of Interior, by Josh C. Toll, Lauren Friedman, Jessica Beess und Chrostin, Carson W. Bennett, Kanzanira Thorington, Matthew Eisenson and Jacob Elkin (May 2024)

• Amicus Brief of Climate Action Rhode Island in Green Oceans v. U.S. Dep't of Interior, by Josh C. Toll, Lauren Friedman, Jessica Beess und Chrostin, Carson W. Bennett, Kanzanira Thorington, Matthew Eisenson and Jacob Elkin (April 2024)

Firelands Wind, LLC (Ohio)

• Amicus Brief of Local Farmers in In the Matter of the Application of Firelands Wind LLC by Michael B. Gerrard and local counsel Trent A. Dougherty (June 2022)

Flint Mine Solar (New York)

• Amicus Brief of Friends of Flint Mine Solar et al. in Town of Copake v. New York State Office of Renewable Energy Siting by Michael B. Gerrard, Matthew Eisenson, and Maureen Crough (December 2022).

South Fork Wind, LLC (New York)

• Amicus Brief of Win With Wind in Citizens for the Preservation of Wainscott, et al v. Town Board of the Town of East Hampton, et al by Michael B. Gerrard (April 2021)

• Legal Strategies to overcome opposition to renewable energy, June 9, 2025
• The Transmission & Interconnection Crises Blocking New York's Climate Goals, May 12, 2025
• Combating Myths and Misinformation about Renewable Energy, September 23, 2024
• Climate LIVE K12: Myths and Misinformation about Renewable Energy, June 19, 2024
• Siting Renewables in New York: Ambitious Climate Goals, a New Siting Process, and How It Is Going, September 22, 2022

• How to Fight Back Against Anti-Renewable Activists, Heatmap Plus, July 24, 2025
• US renewable energy rollout slows amid local opposition, zoning laws, PV Magazine, July 15, 2025
• The Permitting Crisis for Renewables, Heatmap, July 7, 2025
• Powering the Future: Innovative Renewable Energy Projects From Around the World, State of the Planet, April 22, 2025
• A wind project is stalled in New York. Experts worry about impacts across the U.S., NPR, April 17, 2025
• Wind, Solar Backers Have 'Playbook' for Challenging Trump Orders, Bloomberg, March 13, 2025
• 101 West: Is it time to move the needle toward renewable energy, WFMJ, March 6, 2025
• What to Know About Trump’s Executive Order on Wind Energy, FactCheck.org, February 5, 2025
• How to solve local opposition to green development, High Country News, Jan. 24, 2025
• Trump Throws Wrench Into Offshore Wind, Putting New York’s Clean Energy Plans In Doubt, New York Focus, January 23, 2025
• Local Communities Challenge Michigan Renewable Energy Siting Law, CleanTechnica, November 30, 2024
• Under a Texas sun, agrivoltaics offer farmers a new way to make money, Washington Post, September 24, 2024
• Wind farms’ benefits to communities can be slow or complex, leading to opposition and misinformation, Associated Press, July 25, 2024
• How state legislation led the banning of big wind and solar projects in a fourth of Ohio’s counties, Cleveland.com, July 13, 2024
• Report debunks 33 false claims about renewable energy, CNN, June 17, 2024
• Debunking false claims about solar, wind, and electric vehicles, WLFA, Apr. 25, 2024
• Columbia Law report rebuts 33 ‘most pervasive false claims’ about solar, wind, EVs, Utility Dive, Apr. 8, 2024
• Ohio landowners say solar opposition groups threaten their property rights, Energy News Network, Mar. 21, 2024
• What’s slowing down America’s clean energy transition? It’s not the cost, Al Jazeera, Mar. 7, 2024
• Local governments block green energy: Here’s how USA TODAY measured the limits nationwide, USA TODAY, Feb. 4, 2024
• Legislature OKs final bills giving state regulators authority over renewable energy permits, Michigan Advance, Nov. 8, 2023.
• Myths about solar and wind could stall the fight against climate change, Vital Signs, EDF, Oct. 20, 2023.
• Report documents local backlash against renewable energy, E&E EnergyWire, July 20, 2023.
• Opposition to Renewable Energy Facilities in the United States/50-State Survey of Siting Restrictions, JD Supra, June 15, 2023
• Why the pushback against more renewable energy infrastructures?, NPR, June 14, 2023
• Hundreds of US localities restrict renewables siting, with 293 projects currently contested: Columbia report, Utility Dive, June 5, 2023
• The debt-limit deal could help clean energy. But probably not much, L.A. Times, June 1, 2023
• Across the Country, a Big Backlash to New Renewables Is Mounting, News from the States, Feb. 14, 2023
• US: Anti-Renewable Groups Target Whale Deaths, Deutsche Welle, Mar. 6, 2023
• An activist group is spreading misinformation to stop solar projects in rural America, NPR.com, Feb 18, 2023 (radio version for March 16, 2023 All Things Considered linked here)
• Accelerating renewable energy buildout faces big hurdles, even with Inflation Reduction Act: developers, Utility Dive, September 6, 2022
• The Senate has a climate deal. Now comes the hard part, The Los Angeles Times, August 5, 2022
• Hamptons Opponents Hound Offshore Wind-Power Project, Wall Street Journal, Apr. 16, 2022
• As utility-scale renewables expand, some Midwest farmers are pushing back, Grist, Apr. 11, 2022
• Special Report: U.S. solar expansion stalled by rural land-use protests, Reuters, Apr. 7, 2022
• How an Electric Truck Factory Became a Lightning Rod in Georgia, New York Times, March 14, 2022